Types of Roof Shingles
Quick answer: the main types of roof shingles are asphalt (3-tab, architectural, and premium or impact-resistant versions), wood (shingles and shakes), slate, metal shingles and synthetic (polymer) shingles. Clay and concrete tile is often compared alongside them. Asphalt is the most common on American homes. InterNACHI estimates about 20 years for 3-tab and 30 for architectural, while slate can last 60 to 150 years. Your roof's pitch rules some types out, so check it first.
For homeowners choosing a new roof or comparing quotes. This site's calculators are built for asphalt shingles. For other materials, use the roof area from the roof square footage calculator and the manufacturer's coverage.
All types at a glance
Rows fade out where the building code doesn't allow that material at your pitch. Don't know your pitch? Find it here.
| Type | Look | Estimated life* | Minimum pitch (IRC) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt 3-tab | Flat, uniform tabs | 20 years | 2/12 (double underlayment below 4/12) |
| Asphalt architectural | Layered, dimensional | 30 years | 2/12 (double underlayment below 4/12) |
| Impact-resistant asphalt | Like architectural | Not listed separately | 2/12 (double underlayment below 4/12) |
| Wood shingles | Smooth, sawn cedar | 25 years (all wood) | 3/12 |
| Wood shakes | Rough, split cedar | 25 years (all wood) | 3/12 to 4/12 depending on code edition (4/12 shown here) |
| Slate | Natural stone | 60–150 years | 4/12 |
| Metal shingles | Stamped to look like shake, slate or tile | 40–80 years (metal roofing) | 3/12 |
| Synthetic (polymer) | Molded to look like slate or shake | Not listed | Set by the manufacturer |
| Clay or concrete tile | Barrel, flat or interlocking tile | 100+ years | 2½/12 interlocking, 4/12 flat |
*Estimated life from InterNACHI's Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart, which assumes normal maintenance and wear. These are guidelines, not guarantees. Hot climates shorten asphalt shingle life, and severe storms can shorten any roof's life. Minimum pitches from the International Residential Code (IRC) chapter 9. Check the edition your area uses.
Asphalt shingles
Asphalt shingles are a fiberglass mat coated in asphalt and topped with ceramic-coated granules. They're usually the least expensive roof to buy and install, they work on any pitch from 2/12 up, and nearly every roofer installs them. There are four kinds:
3-tab
A single flat layer with cutouts that make three equal tabs. It's the most affordable option, but it comes with shorter warranties (for example 25 years with 60 mph wind coverage for Owens Corning Supreme), and manufacturers are winding down production. See architectural vs 3-tab for the full comparison.
Architectural (dimensional or laminated)
Two layers laminated together for a thicker, textured look. This is today's standard reroof shingle, with longer warranties and higher wind coverage than 3-tab. Most come 3 bundles per square. See bundles per square.
Premium or designer
Heavier asphalt shingles shaped to imitate slate or wood shake, often with bigger, bolder profiles. Some come 4 bundles per square instead of 3, such as Owens Corning Duration MAX and Duration Premium, so check the wrapper before ordering.
Impact-resistant (Class 4)
Built to resist hail, usually with a rubber-like SBS-modified asphalt. The rating comes from the UL 2218 test. For Class 4, the top class, a 2 in steel ball is dropped twice from 20 ft onto the shingle without cracking it. Class 3 uses a 1¾ in ball from 17 ft.
- GAF's Timberline AS II is rated Class 4. GAF's standard Timberline HDZ is rated Class 3.
- Some insurance companies offer discounts for Class 4 shingles. Ask yours before you buy.
- A Class 4 rating is a lab result, not a hail guarantee. GAF notes Timberline AS II is not warranted against hail damage.
Some asphalt shingles are also made in reflective "cool roof" colors. GAF lists its white Royal Sovereign as ENERGY STAR and California Title 24 compliant.
Wood shingles and shakes
Usually cedar. Shingles are sawn smooth and uniform. Shakes are split, so they're thicker and rougher. Both weather to a silver-gray and suit traditional and coastal homes.
- Pros: natural look, lighter than slate or tile.
- Cons: more maintenance, a 25-year estimated life on InterNACHI's chart, and fire concerns. Check local code and any wildfire rules before choosing wood.
- Pitch: at least 3/12 for wood shingles. Shakes need 3/12 or 4/12 depending on the code edition, and steeper slopes allow longer exposure.
Slate
Natural split stone, and the longest-lasting roof on this list: 60 to 150 years on InterNACHI's chart. It's also very heavy and needs specialist installers, so the roof framing has to be checked, and the upfront cost is high.
- Pitch: at least 4/12.
- Reroofing: building code doesn't allow a new roof to be laid over existing slate. It has to come off first.
Metal shingles
Steel or aluminum panels stamped to look like shingles, shake, slate or tile. InterNACHI estimates metal roofing at 40 to 80 years. They cost more upfront than asphalt and need installers who know the system. The minimum pitch for metal roof shingles is 3/12. Metal shingles are different from standing-seam metal panels, which can go on lower slopes per the manufacturer.
Synthetic (composite) shingles
Molded from polymers, often with recycled content, to imitate slate or cedar shake at lower weight. Because they're newer, InterNACHI's chart doesn't list a lifespan for them. Rely on the manufacturer's warranty and testing (impact and fire ratings), and follow the manufacturer's minimum slope.
Clay and concrete tile
Not technically shingles, but often compared with them. Tile is very long-lasting (100+ years on InterNACHI's chart) and very heavy. Code allows interlocking tile down to 2½/12, and flat tile from 4/12.
How long does a shingle roof last?
InterNACHI's estimates for asphalt are about 20 years for 3-tab and 30 years for architectural. What actually decides it:
- Climate: heat and strong sun shorten asphalt shingle life significantly. Hail, hurricanes and tornadoes can end a roof's life early.
- Attic ventilation: a hot, poorly vented attic bakes shingles from below.
- Installation: wrong nailing, missing starter strips or poor flashing cause early failures that no shingle can make up for.
- Maintenance: InterNACHI's numbers assume regular maintenance.
A warranty isn't a lifespan estimate. A "lifetime" shingle warranty is a limited warranty with conditions, and it doesn't mean the roof will last as long as you own the house.
Common signs a shingle roof is near the end: lots of granules in the gutters, curling or cupped shingles, cracked or missing shingles, bare spots, and leaks or stains in the attic. If you see several, get a roofer to inspect it.
Can you put new shingles over old shingles?
Sometimes. Laying a new roof over the old one is called a recover. The IRC does not allow a recover when:
- the roof already has two or more layers of any roof covering,
- the existing roof is water-soaked or too deteriorated to be a base for new roofing, or
- the existing covering is slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile.
So a single layer of asphalt shingles in good condition can often be covered. But many towns set stricter rules, and the new shingle's instructions may not allow it. Even where it's allowed, tearing off is often the better choice: it lets the roofer inspect and repair the deck, and it avoids extra weight and an uneven surface. Check with your building department before deciding.
Going with asphalt? Get your order list.
Bundles, starter, ridge cap, underlayment and ice and water shield, sized to your roof.
Open the shingle calculator →Sources: InterNACHI Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes; IRC chapter 9 (R905 minimum slopes, R908.3.1.1 recover limits) as published by local building departments; GAF pages on impact-resistant shingles, Timberline AS II and Royal Sovereign; Owens Corning Supreme and Duration product data.